Kelly commented on the the determination and sincerity she saw in both boys' performances, and then voted to send Tim Olstad home. Demi admitted to being critical of each of these boys, and was emotional because she didn't want to hurt anyone. Ultimately, she voted for Tim to go home. The toughest decision of the night was in Paulina's hands. She said, "You two are my boys. You're so talented. You both are hard workers. You deliver. You have that great voice, and you are multi-fa-CE-ted." This was the most emotional we've seen Paulina, who ended up eliminating Tim Olstad from the competition. Drawing out the decision makes it harder on the contestants. Once she let Tim go, he was able to breathe again.