It was fun to see baby photos of the contestants. Carlito was an adorable baby...with a mullet. We see why you buzzed your hair, Carlito! America voted for the first songs of the night, and Justin Bieber's "Boyfriend" was selected for Carlito. That's a hard song to sing because it's partially spoken word, but Carlito did well with the high notes. A lucky lady got plucked out of the audience and put on a chair that Carlito danced around.