The judges hated that they had to do this on Thanksgiving, but it was up to them to send either Rion Paige or Josh Levi home. Demi went first, obviously keeping her mentee, Rion. And Paulina followed suit keeping Josh. Kelly Rowland gave each of the singers some constructive criticism, but ultimately voted to keep Josh. The final decision was up to Simon, who said that they're both young and have bright careers ahead of them. We hope Lillie didn't get discouraged by that! Simon wanted the public to decide, so he voted to keep Rion. America's votes were in favor of Rion, so we said goodbye to our comeback kid, Josh Levi. We hope this won't ruin future Thanksgivings for you, but we know your future is bright!